Skip to main content

Comparative Analysis of Caesarean Delivery Rates in a Tertiary and a Secondary Hospitals Using Robson Ten Group Classification

Research Authors
Mamdouh Mohammed Hussein Shaaban, Mansour Ahmed Mohammed Khalifa, Sarah Abdelrahman Ahmed Abdelrahman
Research Date
Research Journal
The Egyptian Journal of Hospital Medicine
Research Year
2022
Research Abstract

Background: There is no justification for any reason to have a caesarean delivery (CD) rate higher than 10–15%. CD rates higher than 10% are not associated with substantial decrease in maternal and neonatal mortality rates. Robson Group Classification System has the advantage of analyzing the caesarean delivery rate in well-defined sub-groups of women that are totally inclusive and mutally exclusive.
Objective: The aim of the current work was to make comparative analysis of increasing trends of caesarean delivery in two hospitals at Assiut Governorate in Egypt.
Patients and methods: This retrospective cross-sectional study included a total of 2702 cases, attending for delivery at Assiut University Hospital; a tertiary hospital and Assiut Police Hospital; a secondary hospital, both present in Assiut Governorate. This study was conducted over 3-month between Jan 2016 to Mar 2016.
Results: Robson Group 5 constituted the most in both hospitals regarding the relative size of the group with higher and significant percentage at the secondary hospital (53%) compared to (32.3%) at the tertiary one. Robson Group 5 contributed the most in both hospitals regarding the overall CD rate with higher and significant percentage at the secondary hospital (74.8%) compared to (49.4%) at the tertiary one. Robson Group 5 also contributed the most in both hospitals regarding the absolute contribution rate of all deliveries with higher and significant percentage at the secondary hospital (50%) compared to (28.7) at the tertiary one.
Conclusion: On the basis of the study, TGCS is only a starting point, but it is important to have a common starting point. Having implemented TGCS, we have concluded that Group 5 (previous caesarean delivery) is the largest of the overall CD rate in both secondary and tertiary hospitals.
Keywords: Caesarean delivery, Assiut Governorate, Robson Ten Group Classification