The approval of the Department of Curriculum and Methods of Teaching on 7/5/2017 on the formation of the discussion and governance committee of the researcher / Mahmoud Anwar Sweifi, the Registrar of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Education (Curriculum and Methods of Teaching Social Studies - History) entitled "Effectiveness of the program based on animation in the teaching of history to develop Skills analysis of political issues and visual thinking among students in the preparatory stage "The discussion and governance committee consists of:1- Adel rasmi Hammad as president and supervisor                  Professor of Curricula and Methods of Teaching Social Studies                                               And Dean of the Faculty of Education - Assiut University2- Prof. Magdy Khair El Din Kamel Member and discussion                 Professor of Curricula and Methods of Teaching Social Studies                      And the Undersecretary of the College of Kindergarten for Graduate Studies and Research - Assiut University3 - Dr. / Khaled Abdel Latif Mohamed Omran Member and discussion                Professor of Curricula and Methods of Teaching Social Studies                        And the Under-Secretary of the Faculty of Education for Graduate Studies and Research - Sohag University4 - Ahmed Zare Ahmed, a member and supervisor               Professor of Curriculum and Methods of Teaching Assistant Social Studies, Faculty of Education, Assiut University